A sincere welcome to the first installment of "I coulda been a contender," the series dedicated to exploring pieces of art (whatever that means (and all media inclusive) ) that had a shot at being great, but weren't, and ended up all the worse because of it. Maybe the missed opportunity was rooted in the idea, the dialogue, the cast, the trailer, a single line, the combination, or something else entirely. The sole, common trait is the special disappointment you'll only find in a work that could have been so much more than it came to be.
The 2007 film I Am Legend will work as a first entry. Whatever your feelings about Will Smith, it's hard to argue that his performance was anything less than good, and perhaps even the slightest bit inspired. The lost family subplot, as obligatory archetypal a setup to establish a broken man as can be found, was dutifully executed, and he somehow managed to pull off the mannequin romance. But...
(1) Superhuman Zombies
Zombies aren't real, OK. Got it. Still, there must be some balance as to what zombies can do, right? If, for example, zombies suddenly start flying, that would be such a departure from human ability that it would pull viewers out of the narrative. So why create zombies possessing borderline supernatural powers that, for example, can abruptly climb street lights with ease? The otherworldly strength transforms the experience from a "what would I do" into a sit and watch because the only bounds of what the zombies might do is what the narrative would require.
(2) Easily Defeated
Paradoxically, the superhuman zombies are way too easily defeated (at times). Anna pulls up with some lights and drives away a vicious horde of zombies? The first point is all about zombies having so much strength that the narrative loses its power because they could do almost anything. Here, a couple of beams of light neuter the zombies. End of story. A woman and her daughter can defeat a horde of zombies. The unstoppable plague is repelled by some UV (SUV?) rays. Just as having impossibly strong enemies weakens the tension of a story, a shortcut to defeat is equally, if not more, unsatisfying.
(3) The Miracle
Unlikely events happen every day, all the time. And it makes sense that movies would focus on narratives that are unlikely, because who wants to watch someone lose the lottery for two hours (though I'm sure the Coen brothers would somehow turn it into a masterpiece.) But, barring some post-post-Coen Brothers-post modernist approach, the "miracle" often turns into a plot point device and in the process loses its worth (if it had any). Anna shows up just in time to save him. A reflection of some deep undercurrent of the resilience of humanity, or an easy (romantic) female character fulfilling the perfunctory need for Will to have something to sacrifice for?
Oh, and this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hORxGgbioWc
No comments:
Post a Comment